4.3.1 EVALUATION OF COMMISSION

The Edmonton Police Commission (Commission) is committed to effective board governance and acknowledges that the process of self-evaluation contributes to increased performance of the Commission as a whole and increases accountability and capacity-building.

Regular self-assessment will ensure that the Commission effectively fulfills its legislative oversight responsibilities and strengthens its governance practices over the Edmonton Police Service.

A formal assessment of the Commission as an entity will assist in identifying strengths, achievements and areas for improvement.

Guidelines:

  1. The Commission will carry out a formal assessment of their performance at a minimum of once per year.  This assessment will measure how Commissioners perceive the Commission is performing its duties. The assessment will focus on the performance of the full board, its committees, and its collective governance oversight.
  2. The Commission will carry out a comprehensive governance review of the Commission as a whole at a minimum of once every four years. This review will assess the state of the Commission’s current governance model and assess processes to ensure they are effective in carrying out the responsibilities of the Commission.  This process will involve input from Commission members, staff, the Chief of Police, and may involve input from other stakeholders as determined by the Commission.
  3. For either of these engagements, the Commission may retain an independent third-party facilitator or consultant. All individual responses shall remain entirely anonymous, and only aggregated data will be presented to the Commission.
  4. Prior to designing and implementing an evaluation process, the Commission will meet to determine the substantive and specific goals and objectives they want to achieve through each evaluation.
  5. The Commission will also meet post evaluation to discuss and reach an agreement on action items and corresponding timelines to address any issues or gaps observed in each evaluation report.
  6. Results from these evaluations will be used to inform strategic planning, policy development and/or revision(s), educational opportunities and address any missing skills or competencies on the Commission.

Revised October 22, 2026